You are here

Erdogan finds himself without allies in beleaguered Idlib

Mar 03,2020 - Last updated at Mar 03,2020

Turkey is now officially at war with the Syrian government in Damascus for the first time since 2011. It is something that few in Turkey and beyond are able to comprehend. How far would Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan go in his latest incursion deep into the renegade province of Idlib, risking his shaky alliance with Russia and reviving the possibility of an all out military confrontation with Moscow?

Last Thursday, Turkey suffered its worst loss in Syria when Syrian jets struck positions south of Turkish observation posts in Idlib, killing at least 34 and wounding dozens. In response, Erdogan gave the Syrian army 48 hours to pull back, promising to launch a full-scale attack. He also told President Vladimir Putin to “step aside” and let the Turkish troops, and its Syrian opposition allies, take care of the regime of Bashar Al Assad.

On Sunday, Ankara sent more troops and heavy armour into Idlib under a new operation called “Spring Shield”, whose objectives remain unclear. On the same day, Turkey downed two Syrian jets over Idlib, while Damascus claimed it shot two Turkish drones. Ankara has used drones and artillery successfully to hit Syrian positions, resulting in many casualties that included fighters belonging to Iranian militias and Hizbollah.

As the Syrian government closed its airspace over the Idlib province, Moscow warned on Sunday that it could not guarantee the safety of Turkish aircraft operating over Syria.

Turkey was shaken when Russian backed Syrian troops began a large-scale military operation to recapture towns in Idlib last December, thus violating a de-escalation deal between Ankara and Moscow under the Sochi agreement. Erdogan watched nervously as Syrian troops took over strategic towns, including Saraqeb, while dealing heavy losses to rebel groups, which both Syria and Moscow consider as terrorists. Moscow blamed Turkey for failing to stick to its end of the bargain by separating moderate fighters from those belonging to Hayat Tahriri Al Sham; formerly Al Nusra.

The Syrian-backed Russian offensive has resulted in a major humanitarian crisis, with tens of thousands of displaced Syrians seeking refuge close to the closed Turkish borders under dire conditions. Turkey says almost one million Syrians have been displaced by the latest offensive. It stated that it could not receive additional refugees.

Putin’s refusal to budge has electrified ties between Ankara and Moscow. Erdogan found himself being dragged into what looked like an untenable situation in Idlib. He turned to the US and NATO, demanding support and asking Washington to deploy Patriot air defence batteries along his border with Syria. So far, the US has not committed and Erdogan only got lip service from his western allies. In response, the Turkish president threatened to unleash a new wave of migrants targeting Europe, and on Sunday he allowed tens of thousands of refugees to head towards the land border post with Greece, which denied them entry.

Putin has resisted holding an urgent summit with Erdogan, although a meeting in Moscow in the coming few days is now being planned. The Russian president is doubling back as his government announced on Sunday that only Russian troops are legally present in Syria. This was a response to Erdogan’s ironic claim that Turkey was in Syria at the request of the Syrian people.

While Erdogan’s bargaining position has improved in the last two days, as his troops made headway in Idlib, his end game is vague. Russia has managed to restrain his military ambitions east of the Euphrates and now he finds himself driven into a possible confrontation with Russia in Idlib. Neither side would want such an outcome, but for Turkey to deny the Syrian army the legitimate objective of liberating its own territory is both puzzling and provocative.

Erdogan has few allies left after breaking up with Europe over Syria and Libya. He seems to be lost between his personal ambitions and the national interests of the Turkish people. His aim now is to push back the Syrian government troops and reach a cease-fire. But then what? Regime change in Damascus is no longer a goal being sought by the US, Europe and even most Arab countries. Russia is pushing for a political process once the liberation of Syrian territory is achieved. Erdogan’s latest gambit is preventing that.

But can he afford to engage in a war of attrition in Idlib; one that could cost more Turkish lives while exasperating a humanitarian crisis and testing the public’s patience at home? His attempt to redefine his goals in Syria, by targeting government forces directly, will be resisted domestically. His party, the AKP, is losing ground and his old allies who helped him solidify his grip on power have walked away from him. Idlib may become his ultimate quagmire.


Osama Al Sharif is a journalist and political commentator based in Amman

41 users have voted, including you.

Add new comment

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
3 + 0 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.


Get top stories and blog posts emailed to you each day.