You are here

Business

Business section

Ireland fines WhatsApp for breaching EU privacy laws

By - Sep 04,2021 - Last updated at Sep 04,2021

In this file photo taken on January 22, 2021 shows a smartphone screen featuring messaging service applications WhatsApp, Signal, telegram, Viber, Discord and Olvid (AFP photo)

DUBLIN — Ireland on Thursday slapped Facebook's WhatsApp messaging service with a record fine for breaching EU data privacy laws after European regulators demanded the penalty be increased.

Ireland's Data Protection Commission (DPC) was entrusted with the case because Facebook's European headquarters are situated in the country.

"And following this reassessment the DPC has imposed a fine of 225 million euros ($267 million) on WhatsApp," the commission said, by far the largest penalty it has ever issued to a company, dwarfing the 450,000-euro fine imposed on Twitter last year. 

As Ireland hosts the regional headquarters of a number of major tech players such as Apple, Google and Twitter, the DPC has been largely responsible for policing adherence to the EU's landmark General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) charter.

But Ireland has come under pressure for not taking a firm enough line against tech giants, who are generally understood to be drawn to the country by its low corporate tax rate of 12.5 per cent.

WhatsApp said it would appeal the decision.

"We disagree with the decision today" it said in a statement, calling the penalties "entirely disproportionate".

 

'Dissuasive fine' 

 

The DPC launched the WhatsApp probe in December 2018 to examine whether the messaging app "discharged its GDPR transparency obligations" with regard to telling users how their data would be processed between WhatsApp and other Facebook companies.

In an initial finding submitted to other European regulators for approval last December, the DPC proposed imposing a fine of between 30 and 50 million euros, but a number of national regulators rejected the figure, triggering the launch of a dispute resolution process in June.

Last month, the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) instructed the DPC to increase the fine, with Germany's regulator leading the calls for the penalty to be higher. 

The EDPB said that the fine had to "reflect a significant level of non-compliance which impact on all of the processing carried out by WhatsApp" in Ireland.

The fine had to be "effective, dissuasive and proportionate", it said. 

Hailed as a potent weapon to bring tech titans to heel, the GDPR endowed national watchdogs with cross-border powers and the possibility to impose sizeable fines for data misuse.

But Germany's data protection commissioner, Ulrich Kelber, in March wrote an open letter criticising the DPC for the "extremely slow" way it handled GDPR complaints. 

Google to appeal 500m euro French fine in copyright row

By - Sep 01,2021 - Last updated at Sep 01,2021

In this file photo taken on May 16, 2019, a man takes a picture with his mobile phone of the logo of the US multinational technology and Internet-related services company Google as he visits the Vivatech startups and innovation fair, in Paris (AFP photo)

PARIS — Google on Wednesday said it is appealing a decision by France's competition watchdog to hand it a 500 million-euro ($590 million) fine in a row with news outlets over the use of their content under EU copyright rules.

"We disagree with some of the legal elements, and consider the amount of the fine to be disproportionate compared to the efforts we have put in place to reach a deal and respect the new law," Sebastien Missoffe, head of Google France, said in a statement.

The fine, issued by the French Competition Authority in July, was the biggest in the agency's history for a failure to comply with one of its rulings. 

The watchdog said Google had failed to negotiate "in good faith" with media companies in a long-running legal battle over the Internet giant's use of snippets of articles, photos and videos in search results. 

The row has centred on claims that Google has used this content in its search results without adequate compensation, despite the seismic shift of global advertising revenues towards the search giant over the past two decades.

In April last year, the French competition authority ordered Google to negotiate "in good faith" with media groups after it refused to comply with a 2019 European Union law governing digital copyright.

The so-called "neighbouring rights" aim to ensure that news publishers are compensated when their work is shown on websites, search engines and social media platforms.

Last September, French news publishers including Agence France-Presse filed a complaint with regulators, saying Google was refusing to move forward on paying to display content in web searches.

While Google insists it has made progress, the French regulator said the company's behaviour "indicates a deliberate, elaborate and systematic lack of respect" for its order to negotiate in good faith. 

The Competition Authority rebuked Google for failing to "have a specific discussion" with media companies about neighbouring rights during negotiations over its Google Showcase news service, which launched late last year.

Missoffe insisted that Google "recognises neighbouring rights, and we remain committed to signing agreements in France".

"We have extended our offers to nearly 1,200 publishers and modified aspects of our contracts," he said, adding that the company has "shared data demanded of us in order to conform to the Competition Authority's decision".

Egypt signs Med-Red Sea high-speed rail link deal

By - Sep 01,2021 - Last updated at Sep 01,2021

CAIRO — Egypt signed a $4.45 billion contract on Wednesday with a consortium including Siemens to construct a high-speed electric rail line between the Red Sea and the Mediterranean, state television said.

The railway will run 660 kilometres between Marsa Matrouh on northern Egypt's Mediterranean coast to the Red Sea port of Ain Sokhna in the east.

State television said the deal covers the design, implementation and "maintenance for 15 years of the [Egypt's] first fast electric train network... worth $4.45 billion".

The project will be carried out by the transport ministry and a consortium of Egyptian and German companies, led by Arab Contractors, Orascom and Siemens, it added.

In February, the ministry announced the end of preliminary work on the project, which is to be completed in 2023.

The line will stop at 21 stations including the coastal city of Alexandria and the country's new administrative capital, some 45 kilometres east of Cairo.

Siemens said on its website that the project will "save passengers up to 50 per cent on travel time" and "ensure faster delivery of goods thanks to creating a rail link from the Red Sea to the Mediterranean". 

Since his election in 2014, President Abdel Fattah Al Sisi has launched several infrastructure mega-projects.

In 2019, Canadian manufacturing group Bombardier announced it had signed a multibillion-dollar agreement to build two automated monorail lines in notoriously congested Cairo.

Egypt's railways have been plagued by a string of deadly accidents widely blamed on crumbling infrastructure and poor maintenance.

US consumer confidence drops sharply in August

By - Aug 31,2021 - Last updated at Aug 31,2021

In this file photo, an employee of the Vermont Creamery displays a free taco voucher after receiving a vaccination against COVID-19 in Websterville, Vermont, on June 29 (AFP photo)

WASHINGTON — Fear of the fast spreading Delta variant of COVID-19 and rising prices undermined Americans' confidence in August, according to a survey released on Tuesday.

The Conference Board said its consumer confidence index fell more than 10 points to 113.8, the lowest since February and the second consecutive monthly decline after the July index was revised down to 125.1.

"Concerns about the Delta variant — and, to a lesser degree, rising gas and food prices — resulted in a less favourable view of current economic conditions and short-term growth prospects," Lynn Franco, senior director of economic indicators at The Conference Board, said in a statement.

The surge in infections and hospitalisations due to the new variant has caused businesses to re-impose mask-wearing requirements, while the end of government stimulus benefits has taken a toll on free-spending consumers. 

At the same time, the recovering economy continues to deal with supply bottlenecks that have sent prices rising.

Franco noted that while plans for major spending — on homes, autos, and major appliances — "cooled somewhat," more Americans are planning vacations in the next six months.

"While the resurgence of COVID-19 and inflation concerns have dampened confidence, it is too soon to conclude this decline will result in consumers significantly curtailing their spending in the months ahead," Franco said.

However, the expectations index which reflects consumers' short-term outlook for income, business and labour market conditions dropped to 91.4 from 103.8.

Consumer views on the current and future prospects for the labour market deteriorated very slightly, while sentiment about business conditions were more downbeat, according to the survey.

Economist Robert Frick of Navy Federal Credit Union said confidence "finally succumbed to the rising COVID-19 Delta wave".

However, he said, "Americans overall are flush with cash and eager to spend it as the economy reopens."

Kuwait aims to transform 'tyre graveyard' into new city

By - Aug 30,2021 - Last updated at Aug 30,2021

KUWAIT CITY — Kuwait on Sunday announced plans to transform what was once a mammoth "tyre graveyard" to a new residential city. 

The 2 square-kilometre dump in the north of the oil-rich Gulf country was where tyres went to die — a total of more than 40 million at the end. 

Seventeen years of tyre dumping and three massive fires between 2012 and 2020 sparked environmental concerns, prompting the authorities to shut it down for good.

"We have moved from a difficult stage that was characterised by great environmental risk," Oil Minister Mohammed Al Fares said at the now empty landfill some 5 kilometres from Al Jahra province.

"Today the area is clean and all tyres have been removed to begin the launch of the project of Saad Al Abdullah city."

In past months, trucks loaded with tyres had made more than 44,000 trips from the landfill to Al Salmi region, near Kuwait's industrial area, where Fares said they will be temporarily stored. 

He said the tyres will be cut or repurposed for local use or for export, adding that storage would meet "international standards... in case of fire".

According to Sheikh Abdullah Al Sabah, director general of the Environment Public Authority, Kuwait plans to recycle all the tyres and avoid the need for another landfill. 

"There is already a factory today that repurposes them, and we hope to find other manufacturer to contribute to help end the tyres issue," he told AFP. 

Alaa Hassan, head of EPSCO Global General Contracting, told AFP her firm extracts raw materials from tyres, including elements used to pave roads and sidewalks. 

She said EPSCO has the capacity to cut or repurpose approximately two millions tyres a year, in cooperation with other factories. 

France's COVID relief spending hits 240b euros — minister

By - Aug 30,2021 - Last updated at Aug 30,2021

PARIS — The French government has extended 240 billion euros ($283 billion) in financial aid to businesses hammered by the coronavirus pandemic since March 2020, mainly in the form of state-guaranteed loans, Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire said on Monday.

President Emmanuel Macron vowed to protect French companies and their employees "whatever the cost" after many were forced to close during three nationwide lockdowns since the outbreak began.

"The bill for 'whatever the cost' stands at 80 billion euros in subsidies and 160 billion euros in loans," Le Maire told France Inter radio.

The aid will now be limited to only the hardest-hit sectors such as tourism and leisure, whose representatives are to meet with Le Maire and other officials later Monday.

The government expects economic growth to hit 6 per cent this year after France and other countries plunged into recession last year.

France's recovery "is going to continue", Le Maire said, in large part thanks to higher consumer spending that is helping the economy operate "at 99 per cent of its capacities".

He added that the number of requests for the state-backed emergency loans fell to just 50,000 in July, compared with 500,000 last May.

Even businesses impacted by the requirement of a "health pass" for clients that proves COVID-19 vaccination or a recent negative test, such as restaurants, museums and cinemas, saw only a temporary drop in activity, Le Maire said.

Starting this week, companies will have to ensure that all employees in contact with the public also have the health pass, as France tries to encourage vaccine holdouts to get the jab.

So far, nearly 72 per cent of the population has received at least one dose — one of the highest rates among Western countries — while 43 million people (64 per cent) have been fully vaccinated, according to the health ministry.

'Desert': Drying Euphrates threatens disaster in Syria

Aug 30,2021 - Last updated at Aug 30,2021

This photo taken on July 26, 2021, shows a view of the Euphrates River near the 1973 Tabqa Dam (unseen) in Raqqa province in eastern Syria (AFP photo)

By Delil Souleiman with Alice Hackman in Beirut
Agence France-Presse

RUMAYLEH, Syria — Syria's longest river used to flow by his olive grove, but today Khaled Al Khamees says it has receded into the distance, parching his trees and leaving his family with hardly a drop to drink.

"It's as if we were in the desert," said the 50-year-old farmer, standing on what last year was the Euphrates riverbed.

"We're thinking of leaving because there's no water left to drink or irrigate the trees."

Aid groups and engineers are warning of a looming humanitarian disaster in northeast Syria, where waning river flow is compounding woes after a decade of war.

They say plummeting water levels at hydroelectric dams since January are threatening water and power cut-offs for up to five million Syrians, in the middle of a coronavirus pandemic and economic crisis.

As drought grips the Mediterranean region, many in the Kurdish-held area are accusing neighbour and archfoe Turkey of weaponising water by tightening the tap upstream, though a Turkish source denied this.

Outside the village of Rumayleh where Khamees lives, black irrigation hoses lay in dusty coils after the river receded so far it became too expensive to operate the water pumps.

Instead, much closer to the water's edge, Khamees and neighbours were busy planting corn and beans in soil just last year submerged under the current.

The father of 12 said he had not seen the river so far away from the village in decades.

"The women have to walk 7 kilometres just to get a bucket of water for their children to drink," he said.

'Alarming' 

Reputed to have once flown through the biblical Garden of Eden, the Euphrates runs for almost 2,800 kilometres across Turkey, Syria and Iraq.

In times of rain, it gushes into northern Syria through the Turkish border, and flows diagonally across the war-torn country towards Iraq.

Along its way, it irrigates swathes of land in Syria's breadbasket, and runs through three hydroelectric dams that provide power and drinking water to millions.

But over the past eight months the river has contracted to a sliver, sucking precious water out of reservoirs and increasing the risk of dam turbines grinding to a halt.

At the Tishrin Dam, the first into which the river falls inside Syria, director Hammoud Al Hadiyyeen described an "alarming" drop in water levels not seen since the dam's completion in 1999.

"It's a humanitarian catastrophe," he said.

Since January, the water level has plummeted by 5 metres and now hovers just dozens of centimetres above "dead level" when turbines are supposed to completely stop producing electricity.

Across northeast Syria, already power generation has fallen by 70 per cent since last year, the head of the energy authority Welat Darwish says. 

Two out of three of all potable water stations along the river are pumping less water or have stopped working, humanitarian groups say.

'Water weapon'? 

Almost 90 per cent of the Euphrates flow comes from Turkey, the United Nations says.

To ensure Syria's fair share, Turkey in 1987 agreed to allow an annual average of 500 cubic metres per second of water across its border.

But that has dropped to as low as 200 in recent months, engineers claim.

Inside Syria, the Euphrates flows mostly along territory controlled by semi-autonomous Kurdish authorities, whose US-backed fighters have over the years wrested its dams and towns from the Islamic State group.

Turkey however regards those Kurdish fighters as linked to its outlawed Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), and has grabbed land from them during Syria's war.

Syria's Kurds have accused Ankara of holding back more water than necessary in its dams, and Damascus in June urged Turkey to increase the flow immediately.

But a Turkish diplomatic source told AFP Turkey had "never reduced the amount of water it releases from its trans-boundary rivers for political or other purposes".

"Our region is facing one of the worst drought periods due to climate change," and rainfall in southern Turkey was "the lowest in the last 30 years", this source said.

Analyst Nicholas Heras said Turkey did hold leverage over Syria and Iraq with the huge Ataturk Dam just 80 kilometres from the Syrian border, but it was debatable whether Ankara wanted to use it.

That would mean "international complications for Ankara, both with the United States and Russia", a key Damascus ally across the table in Syria peace talks.

"The easier, and more frequently utilised, water weapon that Ankara uses is the Alouk plant" that it seized from the Kurds in 2019, Heras said.

Fresh water supply from the station on another river has been disrupted at least 24 times since 2019, affecting 460,000 people, the United Nations says.

'Drought is coming'

But Syria analyst Fabrice Balanche said the drought did serve Ankara's long-term goal of "asphyxiating northeast Syria economically".

"In periods of drought, Turkey helps itself and leaves the rest for the Kurds, in defiance and in full knowledge of the consequences," he said.

Wim Zwijnenburg, of the PAX peace organisation, said Turkey was struggling to provide enough water for "megalomanic" agricultural projects set up in the 1990s, a challenge now complicated by climate change.

"The big picture is drought is coming," he said. 

"We already see a rapid decline in healthy vegetation growth on satellite analysis" in both Syria and Turkey.

A UN climate change report this month found human influence had almost definitely increased the frequency of simultaneous heatwaves and droughts worldwide.

These dry spells are to become longer and more severe around the Mediterranean, the United Nations has warned, with Syria most at risk, according to the 2019 Global Crisis Risk Index.

Downstream from the Tishrin Dam, the Euphrates pools in the depths of Lake Assad.

But today Syria's largest fresh water reservoir too has withdrawn inwards.

On its banks, men with tar-stained hands worked to repair generators exhausted from pumping water across much further distances than in previous years.

Agricultural worker Hussein Saleh, 56, was desperate.

"We can no longer afford the hoses or the generators," said the father of 12.

"The olive trees are thirsty and the animals are hungry." 

At home, in the village of Twihiniyyeh, power cuts had increased from nine to 19 hours a day, he said.

At the country's largest dam of Tabqa to the south, veteran engineer Khaled Shaheen was worried.

"We're trying to diminish how much water we send through," he said.

But "if it continues like this, we could stop electricity production for all except... bakeries, flour mills and hospitals."

'Short on food' 

Meanwhile, among five million people depending on the Euphrates for drinking water, more and more families are ingesting liquid that is unsafe.

Those cut off from the network instead pay for deliveries from private water trucks.

But these tankers most often draw water directly from the river — where wastewater concentration is high due to low flow — and these supplies are not filtered. 

Waterborne disease outbreaks are on the rise, and contaminated ice has caused diarrhoea in displacement camps, according to the NES Forum, an NGO coordination body for the region.

Marwa Daoudy, a Syrian scholar of environmental security, said the decreasing flow of the Euphrates was "very alarming".

"These levels threaten whole rural communities in the Euphrates Basin whose livelihood depends on agriculture and irrigation," she said.

Aid groups say drought conditions have already destroyed large swathes of rain-fed crops in Syria, a country where 60 per cent of people already struggle to put food on the table.

In some communities, animals have started to die, the NES Forum has said.

The United Nations says barley production could drop by 1.2 million tonnes this year, making animal feed more scarce.

Balanche said Syria was likely facing a years-long drought not seen since one from 2005 to 2010, before the civil war.

"The northeast, but also all of Syria, will be short on food, and will need to import massive quantities of cereals."

Downstream in Iraq, seven million more people risked losing access to water from the river, the Norwegian Refugee Council's Karl Schembri said.

"Climate doesn't look at borders," he said.

Stocks rise on Friday as Powell cautious on stimulus withdrawal

By - Aug 29,2021 - Last updated at Aug 29,2021

Traders work in front of a board displaying Germany's share index DAX (background) at the stock exchange in Frankfurt am Main, western Germany, as European stock markets rose,on Friday (AFP photo)

NEW YORK — Stock markets jumped on Friday after Federal Reserve (Fed) Chair Jerome Powell took a cautious stance on a potential withdrawal of the central bank's huge economic stimulus measures later this year.

Major Wall Street indices closed at records after Powell delivered his annual speech at the virtual Jackson Hole central banking symposium, while European trading ended positively after a quiet session.

Powell's address was closely watched for signs of the Fed's plans to reduce the bond-buying that has helped support the pandemic recovery, and for any indications of when the bank could see interest rates rising.

Despite the impact of the fast-spreading Delta variant of COVID-19, Powell said the US economy has continued to recover and shown strong job growth.

But he stressed that there was no hurry to raise interest rates, arguing that current inflation pressures will be temporary, and repeated the Fed's stance that "it could be appropriate to start reducing the pace of asset purchases this year".

His remarks came after some other Fed members had argued that the bank could taper its asset-buying scheme this year.

"We finally heard from the Fed chairman and the markets loved it, even though he said what many had expected, that tapering bond purchases could begin before the end of the year," said Fawad Razaqzada, market analyst at ThinkMarkets.

Powell's comments were "interpreted by the market as the Fed chair offering no fresh news and people who had betted on him providing some clear tapering timeline were left disappointed," Razaqzada said.

Asian markets, which closed before the speech, ended the day mixed.

Powell spoke after new government data showed that a key US inflation gauge climbed again last month and spending slowed.

The personal consumption expenditures price index — the Fed's preferred measure of price increases — rose at a rapid 4.2 per cent pace in July compared to the same month in 2020. 

Spending dropped to 0.3 per cent, in what analysts viewed as a consequence of the Delta variant of COVID-19, making some consumers hesitant.

"While pandemic fatigue is setting in and leading to strong emotional responses, we believe cooler consumer spending growth is more likely than consumers retrenching and the economy going into reverse," Lydia Boussour of Oxford Economics said.

The surge followed a drop on Wall Street on Thursday, with sentiment jolted by geopolitical concerns after a suicide attack at Kabul airport that left scores dead, including 13 US servicemen.

Meanwhile, oil prices, which have enjoyed a strong run this week after recent hefty selling, saw more big gains on Friday as traders bought into the view that the Delta variant's spread will only delay the economic recovery and demand will continue to improve.

OPEC member states and their producer allies will hold their latest virtual output meeting next Wednesday.

Algeria says to divert Spain gas supplies away from Morocco pipeline

By - Aug 29,2021 - Last updated at Aug 29,2021

ALGIERS — Algeria said on Thursday it was ready to divert all its Spain-bound natural gas exports via an undersea pipeline that bypasses Morocco, state media said, two days after Algiers cut ties with its North African rival.

In a meeting with Spanish Ambassador Fernando Moran, Energy Minister Mohamed Arkab stressed "Algeria's full commitment to cover all of Spain's natural gas supplies through the Medgaz" pipeline, said a statement quoted by the official APS news agency.

Algeria exports natural gas to Spain via both the Medgaz pipeline and the higher-capacity GME pipeline which runs overland through Morocco.

But on Tuesday Algiers abruptly cut diplomatic relations with its western neighbour over alleged "hostile actions", accusations the kingdom has dismissed as "absurd".

The rift came just over two months before the GME pipeline, currently owned by Spanish gas giant Naturgy, passes into Moroccan ownership on November 1.

Negotiations over Algeria's continued access to the pipeline had already been complicated by growing strains in ties between Algiers and Rabat.

Last Saturday, Morocco had said it wanted to keep open the GME pipeline, which carries about half of Algeria's gas exports to Spain.

But ties have collapsed, particularly after Algeria accused Morocco of complicity in deadly forest fires that killed at least 90 people.

Morocco's normalisation of ties with Israel last year as a quid pro quo for US recognition of Moroccan sovereignty over the Western Sahara also angered Algiers. 

The Medgaz pipeline's capacity of some 8 billion cubic metres per year to Spain is set to be expanded by 25 per cent later this year.

But this higher capacity alone will not be able to handle what Algeria has historically exported to Spain, according to the Middle East Economic Survey.

But Arkab on Thursday "highlighted recently launched projects such as expansion of the capacity of Medgaz" which Naturgy has said should come online in the final quarter of 2021.

More US firms require vaccine

By - Aug 28,2021 - Last updated at Aug 28,2021

In the wake of full US approval for the Pfizer/BioNTech anti-COVID vaccine this week, more and more American companies are looking at mandatory vaccinations for employees — and customers (AFP photo)

NEW YORK — In the wake of full US approval for the Pfizer/BioNTech anti-COVID vaccine this week, more and more American companies are looking at mandatory vaccinations for employees — and customers.

CVS Health, Chevron, Disney and Goldman Sachs are among the firms who have since told some or all of their workers that inoculations will no longer be optional, requiring proof of shots within a certain time period.

On social media, some of those firms are coming under attack from users who say requiring vaccinations is a violation of personal freedoms, a value near and dear to most Americans. 

One Republican state lawmaker from Florida, Anthony Sabatini, even filed a proposal that would prevent the state's surgeon general from requiring any vaccinations, ever.

But at least so far, amid a surge in coronavirus infections and hospitalisations fuelled by the highly transmissible Delta variant, no public figure is specifically hitting out at corporate America — at least not yet.

For Mark Hass, a professor who specialises in marketing at Arizona State University, even though the crisis is both medical and political it is impossible for companies to thread the needle between liberals and conservatives on the issue.

"The right way to think about this is what's the right thing for our employees, rather than worrying about the safety of our reputation," Hass said.

"Almost every company is going with some sort of mandate or requirement or incentive," he said.

"I think the lack of criticism of corporations is because most of them have acted responsibly in dealing with the pandemic," Hass added, noting the rise of telework.

 

 'Do what I did' 

 

Since June, when banking giant Morgan Stanley and asset manager BlackRock said employees wishing to come into the office would have to provide proof of vaccination, other major companies had made the leap to requiring shots.

Google, Facebook and Uber all joined the vaccination mandate bandwagon.

But the Food and Drug Administration's full approval of the two-dose Pfizer vaccine regimen opened the floodgates, and seemed to cancel out the argument made by some sceptics that full authorisation was needed.

"Do what I did last month: Require your employees to get vaccinated or face strict requirements," President Joe Biden said on Monday. In late July, he had offered federal employees a choice: Show proof of vaccination or submit to regular testing.

Nevertheless, some major groups have yet to budge.

American Airlines is "strongly encouraging" its employees to get injections, but is not requiring them so far. For those who do bite the bullet, the airline is offering an extra day off and $50.

On Tuesday, rival Delta Air Lines said it would charge unvaccinated workers an additional $200 a month for health insurance "to address the financial risk" created for the company by "the decision to not vaccinate", according to CEO Ed Bastian.

Among the largest employers in the country, Amazon, Home Depot, FedEx, UPS and Target have not yet mandated vaccinations against COVID-19. Walmart has so far only asked headquarters employees to get shots, not workers in stores or warehouses.

 

Legal risk limited 

 

Experts generally agree that companies face limited legal liability for imposing vaccination requirements, even if failure to comply leads to an employee being fired.

In May, the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, a federal agency tasked with enforcing laws against workplace discrimination, said an employer's request to show proof of vaccination did not violate American labour law.

Then in June, a federal judge in Houston dismissed a suit brought by employees of Houston Methodist Hospital who were contesting the institution's right to demand that they be vaccinated — a decision seen as one setting a precedent.

And in August US Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett refused to block a plan by Indiana University to require students and employees to get vaccinated.

"By early July, we were pretty confident that mandatory vaccination policies are permissible, so long as you're making the required accommodations necessary for employees with medical conditions or based on religious belief," explains Mark Goldstein, a partner at Reed Smith LLP in New York who specialises in labour law.

"I'm sure you will see some challenges, but the courts and the government do not seem receptive to those arguments," Goldstein noted.

"I think they'll be shut down pretty quickly. I would highly doubt any of the cases will get to the US Supreme Court."

Pages

Pages



Newsletter

Get top stories and blog posts emailed to you each day.

PDF