You are here

Gazan Gandhis: Gaza bleeds alone as ‘liberals’ and ‘progressives’ go mute

May 03,2018 - Last updated at May 03,2018

Three more Palestinians were killed and 611 wounded last Friday, when tens of thousands of Gazans continued their largely non-violent protests at the Gaza-Israel border.

Yet as the casualty count keeps climbing — nearly 45 dead and over 5,500 wounded — the deafening silence also continues. Tellingly, many of those who long chastised Palestinians for using armed resistance against the Israeli occupation are nowhere to be found, while children, journalists, women and men are all targeted by hundreds of Israeli snipers who dot the Gaza border. 

Israeli officials are adamant. The likes of Israeli Defence Minister Avigdor Lieberman perceives his war against the unarmed protesters as a war on terrorists. He believes that “there are no innocents in Gaza”. While the Israeli mindset is not in the least surprising, it is emboldened by the lack of meaningful action, or outright international silence to the atrocities taking place at the border. 

The International Criminal Court (ICC), aside from frequent statements laced with ambiguous legal jargon, has been quite useless thus far. Its chief prosecutor, Fatou Bensouda, derided Israel’s killings in a recent statement, but also distorted facts in her attempt at “even-handed language”, to the delight of Israeli media.

 “Violence against civilians — in a situation such as the one prevailing in Gaza — could constitute crimes under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court... as could the use of civilian presence for the purpose of shielding military activities,” she said. 

Encouraged by Bensouda’s statement, Israel is exploiting the opportunity to deflect from its own crimes. On April 25, an Israeli law group, Shurat Hadin, is seeking to indict three Hamas leaders at the ICC, accusing Hamas of using children as human shields at the border protests.

It is tragic that many still find it difficult to grasp the notion that the Palestinian people are capable of mobilising, resisting and making decisions independent from Palestinian factions. 

Indeed, for the nearly decade-long Hamas-Fateh feud, the Israeli siege on Gaza and throughout the various destructive wars, Gazans have been sidelined, often seen as hapless victims of war and factionalism and lacking any human agency. 

Shurat Hadin, like Bensouda, is feeding into that dehumanising discourse. 

By insisting that Palestinians are not capable of operating outside the confines of political factions, few feel the sense of political responsibility or moral accountability to come to the aid of the Palestinians. 

This is reminiscent of former US President Barack Obama’s unsolicited lecture to Palestinians during his Cairo speech to the Muslim world in 2009. 

“Palestinians must abandon violence,” he said. “Resistance through violence and killing is wrong and does not succeed.”

He then offered his own questionable version of history of how all nations, including “black people in America”, the nations of South Africa, Southeast, Eastern Europe and Indonesia fought and won their freedom by peaceful means only. 

This demeaning approach — of comparing supposed Palestinian failures to others’ successes — is always meant to highlight that Palestinians are different, lesser beings who are incapable of being like the rest of humanity. Interestingly, this is very much the core of the Zionist narrative about the Palestinians. 

That very notion is often presented in the question: “Where is the Palestinian Gandhi?” The inquiry, often asked by so-called liberals and progressives, is not an inquiry at all, but is a judgement — and an unfair one at that. 

Addressing the question soon after the last Israeli war on Gaza in 2014, Jeff Stein wrote in Newsweek: “The answer has been blown away in the smoke and rubble of Gaza, where the idea of non-violent protest seems as quaint as Peter, Paul and Mary. The Palestinians who preached non-violence and led peaceful marches, boycotts, mass sit-downs and the like are mostly dead, in jail, marginalised or in exile.”

Yet, astonishingly, it is being resurrected again, despite the numerous odds, the unfathomable anger and unrelenting pain. 

Tens of thousands of protesters, raising Palestinian flags continue to hold their massive rallies across the Gaza border. Despite the high death toll and the thousands maimed, they return every day with the same commitment to popular resistance that is predicated on collective unity, beyond factionalism and politics. 

But why are they still being largely ignored? 

Why is not Obama tweeting in solidarity with Gazans? Why is not Hillary Clinton taking the podium to address the unremitting Israeli violence? 

It is politically convenient to criticise Palestinians as a matter of course, and utterly inconvenient to credit them, even when they display such courage, prowess and commitment to peaceful change. 

The likes of famed author, J.K. Rowling, had much to stay in criticism of the peaceful Palestinian boycott movement, which aims at holding Israel accountable for its military occupation and violations of human rights. But she became mute when Israeli snipers killed children in Gaza,while cheering whenever a child falls.

The singer Bono of the band U2 dedicated a song to the late Israeli president Shimon Peres, accused of numerous war crimes, but his voice seems to have grown hoarse as the Gaza boy, Mohammed Ibrahim Ayoub, 15 was shot by an Israeli sniper while protesting peacefully at the border. 

However, there is a lesson in all of this. The Palestinian people should have no expectations of those who have constantly failed them. Chastising Palestinians for failing at this or that is an old habit, meant to simply hold Palestinians responsible for their own suffering and to absolve Israel from any wrongdoing. Not even Israel’s “incremental genocide” in Gaza will change that paradigm. 

Instead, Palestinians must continue to count on themselves; to stay focused on formulating a proper strategy that will serve their own interests in the long run, the kind of strategy that transcends factionalism and offers all Palestinians a true roadmap to the coveted freedom. 

The popular resistance in Gaza is just the beginning; it must serve as a foundation for a new outlook, a vision that will ensure that the blood of Mohammed Ibrahim Ayoub is not spilled in vain. 

 

Ramzy Baroud is a journalist, author and editor of Palestine Chronicle. His latest book is “The Last Earth: A Palestinian Story” (Pluto Press, London, 2018). Baroud has a Ph.D. in Palestine Studies from the University of Exeter and is a non-resident scholar at Orfalea Centre for Global and International Studies, University of California Santa Barbara. His website is www.ramzybaroud.net

up
84 users have voted.

Comments

THANKS TO DR BAROUD FOR YOUR INTERESTING ARTICLE THAT ARE BASED ON FACTS AND NOT FICTIONS. EVERYTHING IN THIS ARTICLE WAS CORRECT EXCEEPT THAT DR BAROUD PLAYED IT SAFE BY OMISSION AND POLITICALLY CORRECTNESS. YES, THE WORLD HAS WRITTEN OFF THE GAZANS IF NOT THE ENTIRE PALESTINIANS SIMPLY BECAUSE THEIR ARAB LEADERS ARE PLAYING PORKER GAMES WITH THE SUFFERING OF THEIR OWN. AS ST PAUL SAID, "HE CAME UNTO HIM AND HIS OWN RECEIVED HIM NOT". IF AND WHEN CHARITY DOES NOT BEGIN AT HOME, WHERE THEN WILL " THY KINGDOM COME BE COMMING FROM? " BY THE WAY, NEITHER MR OBAMA NOR MRS HILLARY CLINTON ARE IN OFFICE NOW AND WE ARE ALL THE WITHNESS OF THE FACT THAT THEY HAVE KEEPT QUIET AND REFRAINED FROM COMMENTS PRIVATELY OR PUBLICLY BECAUSE THEY DO NOT WANT TO BE SUCKED INTO THE MESS IN OUR AIR WAVES TODAY. WHAT MORE, HILLARY LOST THE ELECTION, THANKS TO THE VOTES OF THE ARAB AMERICANS AND OUR SO-CALLAED EVANGELICAL HYPOCHRISTIANS SO THERE ARE NO SMOKES WITHOUT FIRE. IT CAN ALSO BE POINTED OUT IN THE ARAB WORLD TODAY THAT THEY NEVER LIKED PRESIDENT OBAMA EVEN AS I WRITE THIS ARTICLE NOW. THE ARAB WORLD NEEDED A STRONG MAN AND THEY GOT ONE SO LET US LEAVE OBAMA AND HILLARY OUT OF THIS ONE AS HISTORY WILL REMEMBER THIS GENERATION AND CORRECT THE FACTS.
**RATHER THAN POINTING FINGERS AT THE WRONG DIRECTION, IT COULD HAVE BEEN NICE IF DR BAROUD HAD AT LEAST MENTIONED THE POSITION OF THE ARAB LEADERS TODAY. I AM NOT SURE IF YOU HAD THE TIME TO READ WHAT ONE OF YOUR LEADERS SAID FEW DAYS AGO, QUOTE, THE PALESTINIANS SHOULD ACCEEPT WHAT EVER THING THEY ARE OFFERED AND SHUT UP. IT WAS NOT OBAMA OR HILLARY THAT MADE THIS STATTEMENT RATHER THAN USING THEIR PETRO-DOLLARS AND POWERS TO LOBBY FOR PEACE. AS LONG AS YOUR LEADERS CONTINUES ON THIS HELPLESS PROJECTILE, THE STATUS QUO WILL CONTINUE.

Add new comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
9 + 6 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Newsletter

Get top stories and blog posts emailed to you each day.