You are here

Winners and losers

Jul 01,2014 - Last updated at Jul 01,2014

If there is anything to be learned from the events of the past few weeks in Iraq and Syria, it is that politics makes strange bedfellows.

The enemies of yesterday could easily become the allies of today, although often only until the winds change direction again.

The United States, Iran an even the beleaguered regime of Syrian President Bashar Assad are scurrying to help the troubled government of controversial Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri Al Maliki.

Even Russia’s Vladimir Putin is stepping in by supplying used SU-25 fighter planes and experts to the distressed Iraqi army, if only to spite the American administration, which is yet to decide if it will sell F-16 jets to Iraq.

The June 10 surprise fall of Iraq’s second biggest city, Mosul, to Sunni insurgents, infiltrated by fighters of the notorious Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, has upset regional and international priorities.

ISIL and its Sunni allies stormed at least three Iraqi governorates and vowed to march on Baghdad to topple the Maliki government.

The autonomous region of Kurdistan did not hesitate to dispatch troops to take over the disputed oil-rich province of Kirkuk. And Shiite religious statements called on Iraqis to protect holy sites in the south from invading Sunni radicals.

Meanwhile, Iraqi leaders are squabbling over a political formula to dislodge Maliki’s eight-year grip on power. He has resisted local and international pressures to step down or form a national salvation government.

But the regional agenda has changed. Suddenly foes and allies are coming together to confront the perceived threat posed by ISIL in both Iraq and Syria. This has set a new dynamics, with the list of winners and losers being rewritten almost every day.

For the time being, here is a look at who appears to have gained and who may have lost as a result of latest events.

Assad emerges as a likely winner as regional and international attention shifts from war-torn Syria to distressed Iraq.

The international community has failed to come up with a political solution to Syria’s civil war and the Syrian president has secured a third term in spite of worldwide condemnation.

His forces have made important gains lately and the rise of ISIL has only cemented his claim that he is fighting radical jihadists on behalf of the West.

As regional and international powers focus on Iraq, pressure on the Syrian regime will decrease noticeably.

Iran too is making gains, for now, as it proves once more that it is an important regional powerbroker.

There are reports that it dispatched advisers from the elite Republican Guards and the Jerusalem Force to Iraq under the command of Major General Qassem Soleimani, who has been active in Syria as well.

It is ironic that both the US, which sent 300 Pentagon advisers to Baghdad, and Iran are working for what appears to be the same objectives in Iraq.

Perhaps the biggest winners are Iraq’s Kurds who are getting closer to achieving their historic dream of declaring an independent Kurdistan.

Their president, Massoud Barzani, said that Iraq has changed since the Sunni insurgency broke out and that Kurdish forces will never leave Kirkuk, adding that the file of disputed territories between Kurdistan and Baghdad has been closed.

Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu declared that his country backs Kurdish independence. The breakdown of Iraq and Syria and the creation of ethnic and sectarian states and enclaves will only bolster Israel’s insistence that it be recognised as a Jewish state.

ISIL, this mysterious organisation that shot up in the last three years, is a likely to make political and territorial gains in the short term.

Symbolically, it announced the creation of an Islamic caliphate in areas under its control and has renamed itself “Islamic State” and proclaimed its leader Abu Bakr Al Baghdadi as caliph.

This development will send waves across the region, especially in the jittery Gulf countries.

It will surely bring together foes and allies to confront this new menace.

The Sunnis of Iraq, who say they are fighting to regain their rights, will soon challenge the new ISIL state, possibly leading to internecine wars.

The birth of a Sunni enclave between Iraq and Syria may be considered a victory, but it will have deep geopolitical repercussions on the neighbouring countries.

Maliki is a likely loser. He has lost the support of most Shiite coalitions, not to mention Kurds and Sunnis, in addition to the important backing of Iran’s Ayatollah Ali Al Sistani.

Iraqi leaders are trying to find an acceptable alternative, one who, according to Moqtada Sadr, will address the legitimate grievances of all, including the Sunnis.

Maliki’s political fate will also be decided in Tehran, which so far supports him. His intransigence, however, will almost certainly suck Iraq into the vortex of sectarian war.

Iraq as a country may still disintegrate.

Another loser is the Syrian opposition, which is now being asked by Washington to join the fight against ISIL in Iraq. 

President Barack Obama said that no moderate Syrian opposition would be able to unseat Assad, but asked Congress for half-a-billion dollars to arm and train the Free Syrian Army (FSA), which has been engaged in bitter fighting with ISIL in eastern Syria.

The US is attempting to repeat the experiment of Iraq’s Awakening forces in Al Anbar by shifting the focus of the FSA from the Syrian regime to ISIL.

One more loser in all of this is Al Qaeda, which had disowned ISIL only to see its influence increase in the past few months.

Already some members of Jabhat Al Nusra, an affiliate of Al Qaeda, have joined ISIL in Bou Kamal, in Syria.

The more radical ISIL becomes the bigger the regional challenge.

One potential loser, in the long run, is the US which, under Obama, has seen its regional influence recede even among its Gulf allies.

For now, alliances are shifting and new ones are emerging. The ISIL factor has made this happen.

The outcome of this political and military reshuffle will dramatically reshape the region.

The writer is a journalist and political commentator based in Amman.

37 users have voted.


Get top stories and blog posts emailed to you each day.